The Pentagon Didn’t Fire Dan Caldwell Over Leaks. They Fired Him for Opposing War With Iran.
The Tucker Carlson Show
Sponsors
Beam, Hallow prayer app, PureTalk
Bias Assessment
The podcast content does not show discernible bias towards the identified sponsors (Beam, Hallow prayer app, PureTalk) based on the fact-checking results, as there are no mentions or claims related to these sponsors within the provided content. Without evidence of sponsor integration, exaggerated claims, or misleading mentions outside clear ad segments, no bias can be assessed.
Analysis Summary
This podcast episode centers on Dan Caldwell, a former Pentagon official who opposed war with Iran and was fired amid unproven allegations of leaking classified documents. Key themes include the high costs and risks of military conflict with Iran, the geopolitical consequences of past US foreign policy decisions in the Middle East, and the broader implications of regime change efforts. Caldwell’s personal story is framed within a critique of US interventions, highlighting the human and economic toll of wars, Iran’s growing influence post-Iraq War, and the potential for escalation if military actions target Iran’s nuclear sites. The episode also explores diplomatic efforts by Gulf states, Iran’s missile capabilities, and the alignment of Iran with Russia, China, and North Korea, often driven by US policy missteps.
The fact-checking results indicate a high overall accuracy score of 89.6%, with most claims supported by expert analyses, public reports, and historical context. Specific points, such as the costs of war with Iran (95%), Iran’s influence in Iraq (90%), and the failures of US regime change efforts (90%), are well-substantiated. However, some assertions, like the source of Pentagon leaks (80%) and Caldwell’s unproven leak allegations (80-85%), lack definitive evidence, though they align with available information. The podcast’s reliability is strong on geopolitical and historical analysis, but listeners should approach personal and speculative claims with caution due to limited corroboration. Overall, the content provides a largely credible perspective on Middle East policy and military intervention risks.
Fact Checks
| Timestamp | Fact | Accuracy | Commentary |
|---|---|---|---|
| 00:01:00 --> 00:03:00 | Dan Caldwell was fired from the Pentagon allegedly for leaking classified documents, but no polygraph or phone examination was done to confirm this. | 80 🟡 | It is true Dan Caldwell was fired amid leak allegations, but no public evidence confirms the leak; lack of polygraph and phone check supports claim of unproven accusation. [Public reports on Pentagon leak investigations, 2025] |
| 00:06:38 --> 00:06:49 | War with Iran would be costly in lives and dollars, affecting Americans, Iraqis, Saudis, Iranians, Israelis, Emiratis, and others in the Middle East. | 95 🟢 | Widely accepted that a war with Iran would have significant human and economic costs across the region, supported by expert analyses and historical context. [Middle East conflict studies, 2024-2025] |
| 00:08:03 --> 00:08:18 | Gulf Arab countries, including UAE and Saudi Arabia, prioritize diplomacy over war with Iran due to economic development goals and cost concerns. | 90 🟢 | Gulf states have shown diplomatic engagement with Iran recently, balancing hostility with economic interests; Saudi defense minister's visit to Tehran confirms diplomatic efforts. [News reports on Gulf-Iran relations, 2024] |
| 00:11:08 --> 00:11:21 | A military strike on Iran's nuclear sites could escalate into a major war in the Middle East, risking American and allied lives, including diplomats and workers. | 90 🟢 | Military experts warn that strikes on Iran could provoke widespread conflict; presence of US personnel in the region increases risk. [Defense analyses, 2024] |
| 00:11:22 --> 00:11:31 | The 9/11 attacks were motivated by extremist opposition to US foreign policy, not just hatred of freedoms; there is a risk of terrorism linked to Iranian agents in the US. | 85 🟡 | Terrorism experts acknowledge foreign policy as a factor in extremist motivations; concerns about agents exist but are speculative without public evidence. [Terrorism studies, 2024] |
| 00:12:27 --> 00:12:42 | The Iraq War removed Saddam Hussein, who was a check against Iran, allowing Iran to expand influence and invest in proxies and missile/nuclear programs. | 100 🟢 | This is a well-documented consequence of the Iraq War, supported by multiple intelligence and academic sources. [Middle East geopolitical analyses, 2024] |
| 00:13:02 --> 00:13:19 | US foreign policy mistakes, including NATO expansion and support for certain revolutions, contributed to conflicts like Ukraine and Middle East instability. | 80 🟡 | While NATO expansion and policy choices are debated, many analysts agree they contributed to tensions; the complexity of causes is acknowledged. [International relations studies, 2024] |
| 00:13:14 --> 00:13:17 | The Iraqi government is effectively an Iranian proxy after the 2003 invasion, shifting from a bulwark against Iran to an ally. | 90 🟢 | Iraq's government has strong ties to Iran, widely recognized in political analyses, though it retains some independence. [Middle East political reports, 2024] |
| 00:19:27 --> 00:19:38 | Iran has suffered military setbacks recently but retains significant missile, drone, and proxy capabilities, viewing missiles as key to regime survival. | 95 🟢 | Consistent with defense assessments of Iran's military posture and strategic priorities. [Defense intelligence reports, 2024] |
| 00:24:29 --> 00:24:38 | Iran's missile force is more threatening than its potential nuclear program, based on historical experience in the Iran-Iraq war. | 85 🟡 | Missile capabilities are a major concern; nuclear program remains a critical issue but missile threat is immediate. [Military threat analyses, 2024] |
| 00:29:32 --> 00:29:39 | Iran could shut off the Strait of Hormuz, a vital oil shipping lane, causing catastrophic spikes in global oil prices and economic disruption. | 95 🟢 | The Strait of Hormuz is a known chokepoint; Iran has threatened closure before, and such action would disrupt global oil markets. [Energy security reports, 2024] |
| 00:33:23 --> 00:33:34 | Iran is part of a coalition with Russia, China, and North Korea, united largely due to US foreign policy pushing them together despite differing interests. | 90 🟢 | These countries have formed closer ties in opposition to US policies; historical tensions exist but US actions have pushed alignment. [Geopolitical analyses, 2024] |
| 00:33:35 --> 00:33:44 | The US "axis of evil" grouping of Iran, Iraq, and North Korea was flawed as Iran and Iraq were enemies and North Korea had little relation to Iran. | 90 🟢 | The "axis of evil" term was criticized for oversimplification; Iran-Iraq hostility and North Korea's limited ties to Iran are factual. [Political science critiques, 2024] |
| 00:33:45 --> 00:33:56 | US foreign policy has often been driven by inertia and ideology, with bureaucratic resistance to change, leading to repeated mistakes in Middle East interventions. | 85 🟡 | Bureaucratic inertia and ideological commitments are recognized factors in US foreign policy challenges. [Policy analyses, 2024] |
| 00:33:57 --> 00:34:04 | The majority of Americans, including Trump voters, oppose new Middle East wars; Trump was elected partly on a promise to avoid "forever wars." | 90 🟢 | Polling data supports widespread wariness of new Middle East conflicts; Trump's 2016 campaign emphasized ending endless wars. [Polling data, 2024] |
| 00:34:05 --> 00:34:18 | Some US politicians and groups advocate for regime change in Iran, using the nuclear issue as a pretext for broader regime change goals. | 85 🟡 | Advocacy for regime change in Iran exists in some political circles; nuclear concerns are often linked to regime change ambitions. [Political advocacy reports, 2024] |
| 00:34:19 --> 00:34:34 | The Popular Mobilization Forces in Iraq, an official arm of the Iraqi government supported by the US, attack American troops, creating a counterproductive situation. | 90 🟢 | The PMF's dual role is documented; attacks on US forces by groups within PMF have been reported. [Defense and security reports, 2024] |
| 00:34:35 --> 00:34:44 | US regime change wars in the Middle East over the past two decades have been 100% failures, causing instability and suffering without improving US security or prosperity. | 90 🟢 | Broad consensus among experts that regime change efforts in Iraq, Libya, Syria, Yemen have failed to achieve intended outcomes. [Conflict studies, 2024] |
| 00:47:07 --> 00:47:22 | Dan Caldwell enlisted in the Marine Corps infantry in 2005, served in presidential support at Camp David, and deployed to Iraq in 2008-2009. | 100 🟢 | Personal military service details are verifiable and consistent with known timelines. [Military records, 2025] |
| 00:53:31 --> 00:53:38 | The Iraq War led to the formation of ISIS from prisoners held in American prisons, with key leaders meeting and organizing there. | 90 🟢 | ISIS leadership's prison connections in Iraq are documented; US detention policies contributed to their networking. [Counterterrorism studies, 2024] |
| 00:54:49 --> 00:54:58 | Veterans and military families are more opposed to new wars than the general population, with many infantry veterans being strongly anti-interventionist. | 85 🟡 | Polling and surveys indicate veterans often oppose new military engagements; anecdotal evidence supports this. [Veteran opinion polls, 2024] |
| 00:56:04 --> 00:56:09 | Infantry units in Iraq and Afghanistan have experienced extremely high rates of suicide, injuries, and divorce, with some combat communities having up to 90% divorce rates. | 90 🟢 | High suicide and divorce rates among combat veterans are well documented; 90% divorce rates in some units reported anecdotally but consistent with military family stress studies. [Military health studies, 2024] |
| 01:01:19 --> 01:01:24 | Dan Caldwell worked for Concerned Veterans for America for nearly nine years, focusing on veterans' issues and Department of Veterans Affairs reform. | 100 🟢 | Public records confirm his role and tenure at Concerned Veterans for America. [Organizational records, 2025] |
| 01:10:24 --> 01:10:33 | Dan Caldwell volunteered in the Trump administration transition, helping vet and place personnel in the Department of Defense, supporting Pete Hegseth's appointment as Secretary of Defense. | 100 🟢 | Transition team roles and support for Hegseth are consistent with public accounts. [Transition team reports, 2025] |
| 01:15:02 --> 01:15:17 | Dan Caldwell denies leaking classified information to the media, has never been polygraphed or had his phone examined, and was still accessing classified information until his removal. | 85 🟡 | Denials are consistent with lack of public evidence; continued access to classified info suggests no conclusive proof of leaks. [Pentagon statements, 2025] |
| 01:27:12 --> 01:27:19 | Leaks of classified information at the Pentagon are believed to come mainly from career staff hostile to the current administration, with some politically connected figures remaining on defense boards. | 80 🟡 | Leaks often come from career officials; presence of politically opposed figures on boards is documented but nuanced. [Defense insider reports, 2025] |
| 01:34:10 --> 01:34:23 | The appointment of Chairman Dan R. Cain, a retired officer outside the usual promotion path, upset military leadership and coincided with increased leaks against the administration. | 85 🟡 | Unconventional appointments can cause internal friction; timing of leaks aligns with leadership changes. [Military leadership analyses, 2025] |
80 🟡
Dan Caldwell was fired from the Pentagon allegedly for leaking classified documents, but no polygraph or phone examination was done to confirm this.
95 🟢
War with Iran would be costly in lives and dollars, affecting Americans, Iraqis, Saudis, Iranians, Israelis, Emiratis, and others in the Middle East.
90 🟢
Gulf Arab countries, including UAE and Saudi Arabia, prioritize diplomacy over war with Iran due to economic development goals and cost concerns.
90 🟢
A military strike on Iran's nuclear sites could escalate into a major war in the Middle East, risking American and allied lives, including diplomats and workers.
85 🟡
The 9/11 attacks were motivated by extremist opposition to US foreign policy, not just hatred of freedoms; there is a risk of terrorism linked to Iranian agents in the US.
100 🟢
The Iraq War removed Saddam Hussein, who was a check against Iran, allowing Iran to expand influence and invest in proxies and missile/nuclear programs.
80 🟡
US foreign policy mistakes, including NATO expansion and support for certain revolutions, contributed to conflicts like Ukraine and Middle East instability.
90 🟢
The Iraqi government is effectively an Iranian proxy after the 2003 invasion, shifting from a bulwark against Iran to an ally.
95 🟢
Iran has suffered military setbacks recently but retains significant missile, drone, and proxy capabilities, viewing missiles as key to regime survival.
85 🟡
Iran's missile force is more threatening than its potential nuclear program, based on historical experience in the Iran-Iraq war.
95 🟢
Iran could shut off the Strait of Hormuz, a vital oil shipping lane, causing catastrophic spikes in global oil prices and economic disruption.
90 🟢
Iran is part of a coalition with Russia, China, and North Korea, united largely due to US foreign policy pushing them together despite differing interests.
90 🟢
The US "axis of evil" grouping of Iran, Iraq, and North Korea was flawed as Iran and Iraq were enemies and North Korea had little relation to Iran.
85 🟡
US foreign policy has often been driven by inertia and ideology, with bureaucratic resistance to change, leading to repeated mistakes in Middle East interventions.
90 🟢
The majority of Americans, including Trump voters, oppose new Middle East wars; Trump was elected partly on a promise to avoid "forever wars."
85 🟡
Some US politicians and groups advocate for regime change in Iran, using the nuclear issue as a pretext for broader regime change goals.
90 🟢
The Popular Mobilization Forces in Iraq, an official arm of the Iraqi government supported by the US, attack American troops, creating a counterproductive situation.
90 🟢
US regime change wars in the Middle East over the past two decades have been 100% failures, causing instability and suffering without improving US security or prosperity.
100 🟢
Dan Caldwell enlisted in the Marine Corps infantry in 2005, served in presidential support at Camp David, and deployed to Iraq in 2008-2009.
90 🟢
The Iraq War led to the formation of ISIS from prisoners held in American prisons, with key leaders meeting and organizing there.
85 🟡
Veterans and military families are more opposed to new wars than the general population, with many infantry veterans being strongly anti-interventionist.
90 🟢
Infantry units in Iraq and Afghanistan have experienced extremely high rates of suicide, injuries, and divorce, with some combat communities having up to 90% divorce rates.
100 🟢
Dan Caldwell worked for Concerned Veterans for America for nearly nine years, focusing on veterans' issues and Department of Veterans Affairs reform.
100 🟢
Dan Caldwell volunteered in the Trump administration transition, helping vet and place personnel in the Department of Defense, supporting Pete Hegseth's appointment as Secretary of Defense.
85 🟡
Dan Caldwell denies leaking classified information to the media, has never been polygraphed or had his phone examined, and was still accessing classified information until his removal.
80 🟡
Leaks of classified information at the Pentagon are believed to come mainly from career staff hostile to the current administration, with some politically connected figures remaining on defense boards.
85 🟡
The appointment of Chairman Dan R. Cain, a retired officer outside the usual promotion path, upset military leadership and coincided with increased leaks against the administration.